| Platinum | Brü Grill & Market |
| Gold | Empanada Man Pizzeria |
| Silver | Red Robin Gourmet Burgers |
| Bronze | Board & Brew-Lake Forest |
| Top Pick | California Fish Grill |
| Top Pick | Forest Cafe |
| Top Pick | Luna Grill Lake Forest |
| Top Pick | Mamons |
| Top Pick | Mulleady's |
| Top Pick | New Shanghai Restaurant |